Showing posts sorted by relevance for query paisley. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query paisley. Sort by date Show all posts

Tuesday, 12 February 2008

Salmon Drift Net Licences

Not so many years ago there were around thirteen drift net licences issued annually. The drive to conserve salmon stocks led to a reduction to six licences and now there are just two. I understand some of the earlier licences were bought out.
My interest in the Portballintrae drift net licence was aroused at the time of the Paisleys Sweeney controversy.
Correspondence passed to the BBC shows that in 2005, both Ian Paisley Sr and his son intervened in a dispute over a drift net licence for a boat registered in Portballintrae.

Mr Paisley Jr supported the claim by the longest serving crew member, Stephen McLaughlin, to inherit the licence.

Stephen had been a crew member on Cecil Montgomery's boat, the Julie M CE 20. Cecil died about three years ago and apparently there was a dispute between Stephen and another member of the Montgomery family as to who could apply for the annual licence. The Montgomery family still have the Julie M but Stephen had no boat.

When a licence holder dies or retires the longest serving crew member gets first call on the licence. At this point the Fisheries Conservancy Board could have refused a licence and thereby reduced the number of licences to one; this would also have meant they didn't have to buy out the licence in the future.
Paisley lobbying prevailed and the licence went to a fisherman with neither boat nor net. Stephen was able to obtain both from Seymour Sweeney and I understand 'drifted' for salmon during his customary two weeks holiday in July. His No1 listed crew member was Seymour.
Stephen handed the licence in after one season and the licence holder for the past two seasons has been Seymour. All caught salmon have to be tagged so should the authorities examine a hotel freezer the number can be traced back to the fisherman who caught it.
Conversations with local fishermen and Portballintrae folks have unearthed a number of yarns. Apparently there was a licence issued in the past and it was signed by a fisherman who could neither read nor write. It's claimed there was an affidavit with three signatures but in less than three handwriting styles. It would appear that some folks on the crew lists over the years have been dry land sailors. Perhaps the fishery authorities have been hoodwinked by wily old sea salts!!

PS I've blanked out personal details such as home addresses and telephone numbers

Update

Tuesday, 15 January 2008

Ian Paisley jnr, Tony Blair, David Hanson and the Saint Andrews Agreement, October 2006

I've just received a copy of a Jim Allister press release containing the following information released under a Freedom of Information request:

Requests to the Government from Ian Paisley Jr.

The Prime Minister has considered your requests and has agreed that we should try to respond positively. I will ask my officials to scope the issues set out below and report back to you once I have considered their findings

  1. £1m over seven years for the North West 200
  2. Resort Spa Planning approval inc. 200 homes
  3. St Pats Barracks - future use to be discussed with MP
  4. Giant's Causeway - Private Sector land to be included in development
  5. A26 upgrade - Ballymena to Ballycastle
  6. Ballee(?) lands - judicial review to be dropped
This letter should be regarded as a statement of intent. I should be grateful if you would provide some further detail on each item. My office will discuss with you at the earliest opportunity.

David Hanson
Minister of State
Northern Ireland Office

Here's a bit more about the Ballee affair, reported on the BBC, from an earlier post on Slugger O'Toole:

Three quotes from Ian Paisley jnr:
“There are six businessmen involved in all of this case” (repeated several times)
“if Mr Sweeney contacted me, of course I did (surely they’re on first name terms by now)
“I have no idea in terms of the business agreement that is in place between my constituents and their business partners ... I’m not privy to any of that, don’t want to be privy to any of that”
I googled with “sweeney ballee” and came up with this (delivered:12/06/2006) and this (Delivered: 16/02/2007) i.e. there has only been one developer in the relationship since February - Junior’s long term associate, Seymour Sweeney, yet Junior continues to fixate on six.
Who were the Six?
“Covenantors" means each of B J Eastwood, Kevin Lagan, Seamus McCloy, Seymour H Sweeney, R John Walker Snr and Thomas Wilson
It was down to Five by May, 2004.
“The members of the consortium were to comprise the appellant and the respondents together with Mr B J Eastwood who subsequently decided not to participate. The solicitors produced a document which was sent to the parties at the end of April 2004, the solicitors stressing that there would be no further amendments to it. It was to be signed by noon on 5 May 2004.”
It was down to One by February, 2007.
Who were the solicitors who produced what subsequently turned out not to be a binding agreement?
When the agreements with the former owners were completed it was agreed that the appellants’ solicitors should be instructed to draw up a written contract to record what had been agreed between the proposed members of the consortium.
The appellant was Seymour Sweeney so were the solicitors, er, Carson McDowell? If so, is there a sufficient separation between property developers and their solicitors and (very) senior civil servants - not to say, ministers?
Junior, apparently, was not privy to any of this ...
NB This might be the resort spa reference on the east bank of the River Bush just north of Bushmills.
Update
Bombshell or damp squib?
BBC report - audio file

Allister follow-up statement

Friday, 16 April 2010

Paisley Thank-you Letter Delayed

Mystery Thank-You

Updated April 26 - also on Scribd




The letter is dated 16 March 2010 yet the envelope is date and time stamped 06.04.10 05:50 pm. Why was there such a delay? Why does Ian jnr make an appearance in the photo? He seems to occupy more of the print than his father does.

Coincidentally, the date of the election was announced some hours prior to the franking of the Paisley thank-you letter.

Ephesians 6:19-20 (King James Version)

19 And for me, that utterance may be given unto me, that I may open my mouth boldly, to make known the mystery of the gospel,

20 For which I am an ambassador in bonds: that therein I may speak boldly, as I ought to speak.


I wonder if Ian snr ever saw that bathroom suite in the piggery.

Added April 17

How were recipients of the letter, immediately following the announcement of an election, expected to interpret the enclosed photo, especially when the son, an election candidate, appears to feature more strongly than the father, the retiring MP?

Who paid for this correspondence to the North Antrim electorate? If the money came from public funds to what account was it charged and when?

A commenter on Slugger O'Toole ponders: "That could play havoc with their election budgets if it was not included! In fact it could render Junior ineligible to take a seat if he won and the budget was exceeded. Interesting to watch how this will play."

A visit to the DUP local advice centres' webpage highlights two other curious features. The sticker on the thank-you letter envelope carries the contact address of Ian jnr, not Ian snr, and clicking on the link to Ian snr's constituency website takes you instead to the European Institute of Protestant Studies. The DUP's Limavady office contains the name of an MP and an MLA, not so the Ballymena office.

Added April 26

Paisley election brochure

No 'Thank You' on this image

Sunday, 28 October 2007

Ballintoy, Knocksoghey and the Blackside

On my grandfather's birth certificate, the place of birth is given as Blackside, Ballintoy, Co. Antrim. The problem is that I can't find Blackside on a map, either on the new OS map or on old ones. I've also searched on the Internet without success. I've tried spelling it differently too. Can somebody help? Peter Corrigan, Sweden

I've only just recently heard of the Blackside. It's in the townland of Knocksoghey - Cnoc Sochai - "hill of the host/army", about one mile east of the village of Ballintoy. Apparently, the sun isn't visible above Knocksoghey from about the beginning of November to the beginning of February.

The Jamieson family have been living at the Blackside for several generations. Visitors to the rope bridge at Carrickarede used to take the old winding path that led from their farmyard down to the bridge. This old pre-1940s postcard [click to enlarge] shows the farmyard with the cornstacks on the east side/right.

The site of the long low narrow building to the west of the Jamieson property featured* in BBC NI's Spotlight programme, "Ian and the Giant", on Tuesday, October 23 past; #111 appears in its 'west wing'.

"A site meeting had been arranged with the planners to lobby and get approval for the site. I was there, Dr Paisley was there, Ian Paisley jnr was there, and Seymour Sweeney, the owner of the property was there" ... Cllr Price McConaghy, Moyle District Council


There was also a picket of local people in attendance that Saturday, September 4, 1999: 'Sometime in the future there will be no-one here but holiday home owners. There will be no natives to tell visitors the history of our area'. [Ballymoney Times]

I'm told that only a very small number of people were permitted onto the site and it's not clear whether or not anyone went inside the buildings to carry out an inspection.

The Schedule of Accommodation page from the planning file matches the following minutes yet, as far as I can see, there was only one dwelling - #111 on the map - and some out-buildings compared with a request for the two replacement dwellings shown on the schedule:

"E/2006/0083/F Sweeney 6 Seaport Avenue, Portballintrae, BT57 8SB. Location 111 Whitepark Road, Ballintoy. Proposed alterations and extension to underground area of extant planning approval E/1999/0380/F (presently under construction)." ... Moyle Council Minutes, 21 August 2006

Didn't the planners and those lobbying for the application spot the discrepancy? 'Presently under construction' is hardly a useful description for a large hole in the ground with a tracing of concrete; there's not much to see for eight years work. And there's more ...

Property #4, in the 1901 Census - see comment #2 - shows one dwelling, a stable, a cow house, a piggery, a barn and a shed. Local people say that the dwelling was at the west/left end and the stable, barn, piggery and byre were to the right of it. The barn once had an indoor threshing mill and the horse-walk was on the seaward side.

I'm told that prior to the site meeting contractors 'refurbished' the outbuildings; apparently #111 had been improved with a Housing Executive grant in the mid 1980s.

We've all heard about old time farming where the pigs were kept in the parlour but who'd have expected to find a bathroom suite in the piggery!! Whoever thought of this wheeze apparently had only arranged for the connection of a cold water supply and, as there was no connecting door, the lady of the house would have been expected to make her way to the cold ablutions via the garden or yard - a blue Blackside backside in the parish of Ballintoy!!

The late Cllr Bertie McKay of Portbraddon told me that the authorities were invited to check the plumbing but it seems that the planning service and the lobbyists may not have got the message.

The 4th and 5th revaluations at the (former) Valuation and Lands Agency site show a #111 and #111a, VLA Property References: 2113061201110004 and 2113061201110101. The old sow, OOPS, lady of the house would have got a bit of a shock if a bill from the rates collection folks for 111a had dropped on the floor. An acquaintance of mine has queried the bill for 111a and was told that if anyone was that anxious to pay rates the office would happily have supplied a bill - or words to that effect!!

The buildings were tumbled shortly after the 'successful' site meeting and there's now a huge hole in the ground where the imagined dwelling used to be. There's a splendid view out to Sheep and Rathlin Islands but what exactly is the purpose of the hole. If it's for a lower level apartment then an extensive amount of rock would need to be quarried on the north side of the hole.

It's difficult to see how the planning service would permit this quarrying considering current regulations. Who knows? The some time lobbyist who failed to spot the peculiar plumbing in the piggery is now the First Minister and the Minister for the Environment belongs to the same party. This may be the story of a dripping tap rather than a smoking gun and a Dr Yes rather than a Dr No.

Yes, First Minister ....

*I'm told this was edited out of the broadcast program.

Thursday, 16 April 2009

Ian Paisley jnr and No 1 Ballyallaght Farm Cottages

Is Ian Paisley jnr no longer No 1? The end of terrace or semi-detached property with the blinds drawn is currently on the market for £250,000 plus. There are other town-houses nearby starting at £147,000. House prices, in a surreal manner, have followed the career of the former junior minister: a steady heady rise followed by a sharp fall.

Perhaps a politician from a rival party or a rival from the same party (DUP) will step in and purchase this highly desirable property with its 'panoramic sea views overlooking Rathlin Island and beyond.'

Saturday, 21 June 2008

New Rathlin Ferry Operator 3

I've uploaded a copy of today's News Letter story on the Rathlin ferry contract for the benefit of islanders who don't have ready access to the paper. [Just click on the image to enlarge it]

This story looks even more intriguing than events surrounding the recent Ian Paisley jnr saga. It involves Ministers, civil servants and consultants from Stormont in Belfast, the Dáil in Dublin and Holyrood in Edinburgh. Viewers of earlier accounts on the blog have come from these cities as well as from Cork and Glasgow.

Martina Purdy, in the Devenport Diaries, has solved one mystery involving Rathlin Island and Conor Murphy, Minister for Regional Development, but perhaps she should have taken off her shoes, put on a pair of robust boots and dug a little deeper.

The DRD spokeswoman claims that 'detailed consideration' was given to the relevant aspects of the bids. Did this include the relatively simple process of googling with words and phrases such as 'o'driscoll', 'cape clear', 'o cuiv' and 'dáil'? My googling brought up some of the links and quotes in the two earlier threads. Presumably politicians, journalists and other ferry operators may well have done the same; they'll also have used 'rathlin ferry operator'.

The spokeswoman refers to an improved level of service but what happens when the mv Canna is out of service for a few weeks for its annual overhaul? Is there an equivalent back-up? My conversations so far indicate that there isn't.

Much has been made of the catamaran. Is the £1.2m capital spending in the ISNI documents linked to it? The £6.3m is linked to new ro-ro ferries. What sort of a catamaran would you get for £1.2m and how useful would it be in the treacherous tidal conditions that exist between Ballycastle and Rathlin?

Going through [a tide rip] can be an exhilarating experience in a well found boat of adequate size but more often a frightening one in an open boat, particularly when the stream is running against the wind. The waters really roar as they tumble round the boat's gunwhale.


Perhaps Ministers Murphy, Dodds and Empey should reflect on the answers that will be produced for Tuesday's questions before they commit themselves further to this project. If it disintegrates the main losers are likely to be the islanders who depend on this lifeline ferry.

Adds

Some more disturbing news from Ciaran O'Driscoll's newish ferry operation in the South-West:

Cape Clear News 17th June 2008


Tidy Island:

Some of our readers will have received notice of the removal from service of the Naomh Ciaran, the State subsidised lifeline ferry, recently, which occasioned the notice. This was because the addition of a larger crane to the boat brought into doubt her stability and she was impounded by the Marine Survey Office.

I understand that she is expected to be back in service tomorrow morning.

Did he make changes to the ferry without notifying the Marine Survey Office? Is a prosecution pending? Presumably our own Maritime and Coastguard Agency (MCA) will/may be making a careful note of these events now that they will be responsible for O'Driscoll ferries here. MCA is an agency of the Department of Transport under Minister Ruth Kelly.

Adds

Here are some commitments from Paul Priestly, DRD Permanent Secretary, in the department's corporate and business plans:

DRD is a strong and capable organisation. But we recognise that we need to continue working hard to build the Department’s capability for the future. To this end, over the next 18 months the Departmental Board will lead a Change and Improvement Programme – which we have called the ‘3Cs Programme’. It is about ensuring a Capable, Committed and Confident DRD – a department which:

• has the Capablity in terms of competence and capacity to achieve its objectives;
• is Committed to delivering improved public services; and
• has staff who are Confident in their own abilities and those of their colleagues – including their managers.


I've looked for a mention of £1.2m capital spending on the Rathlin ferry and £6.3m on Rathlin ro-ro ferries - alongside the figures for other infrastructure spending - but could only find this:

• an enhanced ferry service for Rathlin Island by 2009


Why such coyness about a lifeline ferry service? It would seem to be at odds with DRD transparency and accountability requirements in the context of Civil Service core values: integrity, honesty, objectivity and impartiality.

Joanna Tuffy questions Eamon O Cuiv re.ferry services in West Cork.

Ciaran O'Driscoll's West Cork Coastal Cruises seeks Leader funding for boat. Funding awarded.

Adds June 23

I've just checked out the passenger carrying status of the Naomh Ciaran 2. Marine Survey Office, Dublin, records show that the certificate expired on April 26, 2008, for trips around the Fastnet lighthouse (summer 50/winter 50) expired on October 28, 2007, for trips between Baltimore, Schull and Cape Clear (summer 100/winter 0) and the ferry's name is missing from the June listing. I spoke to MSO and was told that the (impounded) ferry has been given clearance to operate whilst the paper work is being updated. And I thought maladministration was a condition that afflicted Ian Paisley jnr

New Rathlin Ballycastle ferry timetable

It would appear that the fares have doubled in price. The current fares are £10 adult return, £5 child return; the new ones £10 adult single, £5 child single.

The mv True Light has a ten minute turn around time. Is this sufficient to offload passengers, load new passengers and cover safety aspects of the trip?

For some curious reason the True Light's name does not appear on the flyer. Is a different boat to be used now? If there was a change, when did it take place? Are there implications for the claims made during the tendering process?

Is inappropriate political pressure being brought to bear on CMAL to lease the mv Canna to the new operator, Rathlin Island Ferry Limited?

Adds June 24

My political and journalistic sources tell me that Crockard Communications is assisting one of the parties to this affair.

Crisis management • Supporting you when things go wrong

So who's in trouble?

New Rathlin Ferry Operator 4

Tuesday, 20 September 2011

Dark Hedges, Ballymoney - An Abuse of Heritage?

click image to enlarge

Questions have been asked about a sheep-wire fence topped with barbed wire that has recently been erected at the Dark Hedges, one of North Antrim's iconic beauty spots which lies about 5 miles ENE of Ballymoney, Co Antrim. The new fencing is far more visually obtrusive than the old.

  • If such fencing was necessary could it not have been placed behind the trees? 
  • Is it currently permissible to put barbed wire atop a new roadside fence?
  • What were the terms of the application for Heritage Lottery Funds?
  • What conditions were attached to the HLF grant?

The Dark Hedges Preservation Trust, a body containing local landowners, a local councillor, a tree specialist and other interested members of the public, has received £43,000 from the Heritage Lottery Fund. According to the Fund, in a letter to Ian Paisley jnr MP, the project 'aims to conserve an ‘avenue’ of 150 beech trees, and to increase awareness at a local and national level of the cultural and historical significance of veteran trees'.

You Tube - The Dark Hedges

Dark Hedges to feature in Countryfile 2012 calendar

Heritage Lottery Fund Application

Summary of progress

06 Dec 2010 - "Congratulations, Heritage Trust, you have been awarded a grant of up to £43,000." .. "You must provide with the Permission to Start form evidence of a full lease .." The project must begin within twelve months of the December 6, 2010 letter and there may be penalties if the project commences prior to permission being given.

12 Oct 2011 - Even though fencing has begun the project "has not yet had [HLF] permission to start".

Thursday, 10 April 2008

When DUP Politician Met An Irish President

The year was 1991 and the Democratic Unionist Party was in no mood to extend the hand of friendship across the border.

A problem arose when Co-Operation Ireland invited a delegation from Moyle District Council to meet President Mary Robinson. The meeting was arranged for September 19.

James Rodgers DUP (back row, 1st from left) was one of the nominees and he was delighted to go as he appreciated the President's earlier decision to resign from the Irish Labour Party when the Anglo-Irish Agreement was signed over the heads of the Unionists.

Peter Robinson, DUP MP for East Belfast said: "Our view has always been that there should be no formal contacts of this kind until the Dublin Government drops its claim to our territory."
The DUP's deputy press officer, Nigel Dodds, was unable to confirm whether the Rodgers had been officially expelled, but said they should have used official party procedures to air their grievances.
Councillor Rodgers defended his position by recalling: "There were DUP councillors who met NIO ministers when the ban was in place and there was no action taken against them. I would expect to be treated the same."

The councillor blotted his copy book even further by later proposing that the council invite the President to visit the district.

Fast forward to 2008 and all has changed utterly. Ian Paisley, who'd once shunned a DUP council member for greeting a southern President who'd supported the Unionists, now finds himself sharing an office with SF's Martin McGuinness, attending meetings of the North South Ministerial Council and rolling out the red carpet in Ballymena for An Taoiseach, Bertie Ahern.

Friday, 1 February 2013

Coastguard SOS Campaign - What Your MP Thinks

Northern Ireland Sector

Coastguard SOS emailed (on four separate occasions) and asked a straightforward question of all Westminster MPs: to confirm whether they are FOR or AGAINST planned closures of maritime rescue & coordination centres. (MRCC’s)


According to the Coastguard SOS website, twelve of the eighteen Northern Ireland MPs responded and answered AGAINST: Gregory Campbell, Nigel Dodds, Jeffrey Donaldson, Sylvia Hermon, Naomi Long, William McCrea, Alasdair McDonnell, Margaret Ritchie, Jim Shannon, David Simpson and Sammy Wilson. Coastguard SOS wishes to hear from Michelle Gildernew, Martin McGuinness' successor, Paul Maskey, Conor Murphy and Ian Paisley jr.

MPs have a special duty to their constituents but they also have a general duty to all constituents.

Earlier cross-party support for the Save Belfast MRCC in Bangor.

Saturday, 6 October 2007

Celtic "Tiger Fish"

A friend of mine claims he saw two well known local personalities aboard the Tiger Fish - the two Gentleman of Girona - Ian Paisley jnr MLA and Seymour Sweeney. Both are in the eye of the storm that has engulfed the proposed Giant's Causeway Visitor Centre; there are possible implications for the future of the planning process. The Tiger Fish is currently berthed in Ballycastle Marina so that should please the ratepayers of Moyle. [Click on image to enlarge]

Some wit has been having a little bit of fun:

AND it came to pass in the year 2007, that verily, the Lord came unto Noah, who was now living in Ballymoney, and said, “Once again, the earth has become wicked and over-populated, and I see all manner of evils, terrorists in government and the end of all flesh before me. Build me another Ark and save two of every living thing

Tuesday, 4 March 2008

Giant's Causeway Visitor Centre - Official Papers 2006


These official papers from 15 November 2006 outline some of the difficulties associated with the construction of a new visitors centre at the Giant's Causeway. They also detail the extensive lobbying by Ian Paisley jnr on behalf of one of his constituents, Seymour Sweeney, the local property owner, developer and DUP member.

Saturday, 21 May 2011

Angela Lansbury and the Belfast McIldowie Connection

Nelson McCausland's mention of Angela Lansbury and her Belfast roots set me off on a little tour of the internet and other resources this afternoon.  Angela's mother was Charlotte Lillian McIldowie (1895-1975), better known by her acting name Moyna Macgill.

Charlotte, aged 5, appears in the 1901 Irish Census in Cranmore Park, Belfast, along with her solicitor father William (aged 37, Presbyterian, born Co Down), mother Elizabeth Jane (aged 33, nee Mageean, born Co Antrim) and siblings James Mageean (aged 8) and Margory Graham (aged 4 months). Elizabeth Jane was born on 17 May 1867, the daughter of James Mageean and Margaret Graham; her parents were married in Drumbo, Co Down, on 21 September 1860.

Charlotte, by then aged 15, doesn't appear in the 1911 Irish census, nor does her mother and brother James, but by this time other members of the family are now living in Deramore Avenue: William (47, born in Belfast, married 19 years, four children born and still alive), Marjory Graham (10, born in Bangor, Co Down) and Dennis William (7, born in Belfast).

PRONI Will Calendars provides the following abstract for William: McIldowie William of Sandymount Deramore Drive Belfast solicitor died 30 September 1929 at Westgate-on-Sea [Kent] Probate Belfast 23 June to William Hunter solicitor's assistant. Effects £16903 7s.

The Lennon Wylie website sheds additional light on the whereabouts of this McIldowie family with the aid of Belfast street directories:

1880 - McIldowie, George, Hopeview Cottage, Strandtown, Co Down

1907 - McIldowie, G., & Sons, Solicitors, 26 Corn Market; res., G. McIldowie, 31 Kirkliston Drive; George McIldowie, jun., Elphinstone, Craigavad; and William McIldowie, Sandymount, 23 Deramore Drive

1910 - McIldowie, G., & Sons, Solicitors, 26 Corn Market; res., George McIldowie, jun., Elphinstone, Craigavad; and William McIldowie, Sandymount, 17 Deramore Drive

PRONI street directories yield:

1890 - McIldowie, George & Sons, 26 Corn Market - George, George jnr and William, Kin-Edar, Strandtown.

1895 - McIldowie, Wm of Geo McIldowie & Sons, 3 Tudor Gardens, Eglantine Avenue.

"Scots Kith and Kin" refers to the McIldowies as septs of the MacLeans of Duart, Cameron, Lamont and MacGregor.

Scotland's People: "The gaelic Mac Ghille dhuibh, or “son of the black lad”, seen in the surnames Macilduy, Macildue and Macildowie, translates to Black".

Charlotte's grandfather, George McIldowie, is recorded in the 1901 census. This George (aged 64, solicitor, living in Sydenham Avenue) was born in Paisley, Scotland; his wife Charlotte Mantell (aged 60) was born in Irvine, Scotland; their son Louis Mantell McIldowie [born 08 March 1877 - familysearch.org] was one of the inventors of a new apparatus for cleaning windows whilst living in London. Belfast Cemetery records - City Cemetery: Charlotte, Belgravia, Kirkliston Drive, Bloomfield, died 21 September 1908, aged 68; George, Fountainvale Avenue, died 29 November 1910, aged 74.

Sunday, 9 November 2014

#SaveTheDal - Letter to the Minister

UPDATED

Copy of letter from local GPs to Health Minister:

Mr Jim Wells 
The Minister
Department of Health, Social Services and Public Safety
Information Office
C5.20 Castle Buildings
Stormont Buildings
Belfast
BT4 3SQ

Dear Mr Wells,

As you are aware Dr Tony Stevens, Chief Executive of NHSCT announced on Thursday 30th November 2014, the “temporary” closure of Dalriada Hospital in Ballycastle in its entirety at the end of November 2014.

Dalriada Hospital has provided outstanding medical care to the people of Ballycastle and the surrounding areas for decades.

This decision to close Dalriada hospital betrays the substance of Transforming Your Care which promotes intermediate care, with medical care being provided to patients either in their own homes or in intermediate care units as close as possible to their homes.

As GPs who work in Dalriada Hospital we wish to voice our grave concerns about the proposed closure of Dalriada Hospital. Although described as a “temporary” closure, Dr Tony Stevens CEO was unable to give any assurance that this would be the case, merely advising that there would be consultation about the provision of intermediate care throughout the Northern Trust area after the end of this financial year. He also stated that as this was “temporary” he was under no obligation to carry out any consultation.

The hospital encompasses 20 intermediate care beds and 12 regional Multiple sclerosis respite beds. Not only do we the GPs accept patients on a step-down basis from the acute hospital setting (e.g. for rehabilitation following orthopaedic surgery for fractured hips) we also provide a step-up service.

The step-up service allows us to directly admit a patient from home, including Rathlin islanders to Dalriada Hospital who would otherwise require attendance at A+E and admission into an acute hospital bed. As you are aware the cost of a bed day in Dalriada Hospital is a fraction of the cost of a bed day in the acute hospital setting such as Causeway or Antrim Area Hospital.

The doctors also accept and provide medical cover for patients who have been assessed in A+E or admitted to the medical assessment unit and require further short-term clinical care and rehabilitation with the assistance of the multidisciplinary team.

Unfortunately the number of patients requiring complex palliative care treatment has escalated in the past years and Dalriada hospital has highly skilled clinical staff members who are fully dedicated and competent to provide this essential service to patients who otherwise their care could only be provided in the acute hospital setting.

Dalriada hospital also provides a regional respite service for patients with Multiple Sclerosis who have complex medical and nursing needs. During their respite stay the service users avail.

The many services on site including dentistry, podiatry, physiotherapy and occupational therapy. This prevents fragmented care at home. Sadly many of these patients are young. A nursing home environment would be totally unsuitable to their needs. This has been continually voiced by the Multiple Sclerosis Society.
The clinical care provided by the specialist nurses in Dalriada Hospital provides not only for the physical complexities, but also the psychological and social needs of the sufferers of Multiple Sclerosis and their families. This is unique and has been emphasised by the service users and reiterated in the media.

The disbandment of the hospital and these specialist skilled staff will have enormous clinical impact on the provision of acute hospital care and would appear to make no economic sense.

As GPs we are fearful of the impact this proposed major cutback in local healthcare provision will have on the patients in our practices populations. North Antrim and Rathlin Island have become popular retirement areas and hence we have a large proportion of frail elderly patients. In the winter months particularly, many of these patients unfortunately succumb to respiratory infections and fractures due to falls. The only option for these patients will be to attend A+E with long trolley waits and prolonged stay in acute hospital beds. These patients have been treated and have had rehabilitation (including after orthopaedic surgery) up to the present time in Dalriada hospital.

The Northern Trust representatives have argued that they have too many intermediate care beds. Unfortunately they have been disingenuous in their description of intermediate care beds. At present the only intermediate care facilities in the NHSCT area which are staffed by trained nurses are:
• Dalriada Hospital with 20 intermediate care beds. 
• Robinson Hospital in Ballymoney with 21 intermediate care beds 
• Inver in Larne with 16 intermediate care beds 
• Mid Ulster hospital in Magherafelt which has 3 assessment beds.

All the other units which the trust has called intermediate care beds are staffed by care assistants with no trained nurses. Patients can only be admitted to these care assistant staffed units if;
• they can be cared for with the assistance of one person, 
• if they do not have dementia and 
• If they do not have medical complications requiring skilled nursing care.

These care assistant staffed units are in Ballymoney, Ballymena, Antrim, Larne, Whiteabbey and Cookstown. None of these are within easy access of Ballycastle and the Glens.

1. If this proposed closure is enforced what is going to happen to the patients in this area of North Antrim and Rathlin Island?
2. Where are our patients with complex palliative care needs going to be admitted?
3. Can you give assurances that our frail elderly patients will not spend prolonged undignified days on A+E trolleys?
4. Where will the clients with Multiple Sclerosis avail of respite care?

The haste with which this announcement was made has caused enormous anxiety to the people of Ballycastle, Rathlin Island and the Glens. Unfortunately without the answers to the questions we pose we have been unable to allay these fears and anxieties. We would invite you to reply urgently to our questions so that we can assure our patients of a safe and high standard of medical provision.

We would also invite you to come to Dalriada hospital to see for yourself the excellent facilities which it provides, a service which actually saves the Health service money. You will be assured of a very warm welcome.
Yours sincerely,
Dr Mary McLister
Dr Martin O’Kane
Dr Bernie Hegarty
Dr Fergal Hasson
Dr Farah Nawaz
Dr Adrian Sterne
Dr Ian Hadden
Dr Stephen McDonnell
In support of: Dr Dermot Grant, Dr John McSparran and Dr Gillian Elder, Glens of Antrim Medical Centre
CCs
Mr Tony Stevens Chief Executive
Cllr Donal Cunningham
Cllr Joan Baird
Cllr Cara McShane
Ian Paisley MP
Robin Swann MLA
Jim Allister MLA
Daithi McKay MLA
Mervyn Storey MLA
Northern Local Commissioning Group

Public meeting to support campaign to keep Dalriada Hospital open arranged for Tuesday 18 November at 7pm in Dunluce School, Bushmills.

Dalriada Hospital, Ballycastle, Cuts - Action and Reaction

Coleraine Times slideshow of Public Meeting [Photos by Kevin McAuley; Slideshow by Una Culkin]

UTV coverage of white-line protest

Ministerial office email address for submission of views: private.office@dhsspsni.gov.uk 

Added November 10

Call for judicial review over Dalriada [UTV]

"Philomena McKay has instructed her lawyers to seek a judicial review following the temporary closure of Dalriada Hospital in Ballycastle, Co Antrim.

She said the application is being taken on the basis that the Northern Trust "failed to carry out adequate consultation with patients and staff before the decision was taken".

Ms McKay, who said she relies on the respite centre, added that while officials maintain that the closure is temporary, many of those who use it are concerned it will become permanent."

Written answers to questions 25 February 2011:

"Regional MS Respite Centre at Dalriada Hospital, Ballycastle

Mr M Storey asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety to outline his Department's plans for the continued provision of Multiple Sclerosis services at the Regional MS Respite Centre at Dalriada Hospital, Ballycastle.
(AQW 3590/11)
Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety: The Northern Health and Social Care Trust is committed to sustaining respite care and has no plans to change services at Dalriada Hospital in North Antrim, for Multiple Sclerosis respite or for other services. The Trust has sought initial views from existing MS respite service users on future service provision, and any plans for changes in service provisions will follow discussions with those who use services."

Did such discussions with users take place prior to the 'temporary' closure announcement?

Ballycastle Chronicle: Route Presbytery behind Dalriada